stanley15's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Black History Music Video]

great

that i was awesome even though i dont like rap the best that video was still awesome great job

[Vermilion pt.2]

sad

man that was great ive watch all of your vidoes and they all rock you just are awesome colin cove im glad i can watch some good movies on newgrounds because of you

23450 responds:

Well, im very glad you liked it. Hopefuly you enjoyed watching all of my stuff as much as i enjoyed making them, as cliche as that sounds, its the truth. Cheers.

[Syphen Transformation]

sweet

that was awesome the drawings were a little poor but still better than me and the music fit good
also if you would have made the two guys fight that would have been good too but otherwise i love it
the picture at the end was really cool

23450 responds:

I was still pretty inexperianced with flash at this time. First time getting through, i was pretty happy with it. And thanks for enjoying the pic, happy you liked it.

[Rundown (Provincials)]

good

for made in 13 hours great the music and theme was great and i like when the buuny smiles at the end that was funny your button at the end to find out how you got sreawed out of 1st place did work but i really want to know how that sounds funny

23450 responds:

Basicly, the guy who won the competition was a terrible animator. My animation blew him out of the water. And his father was one of the guys heading the competition. I put the two and two together.

That was years ago now. I now realize that he may have followed the theme better then I did. So its kinda like having a competiton between chicks, basing it on looks and personality. My flash would be the hot chick with little to no personality. It would be unfair to pick mine over the other, being a deacent looker, but having a better personality.

Wierd metaphor, but it works for me. lol.

[Right Where it Belongs]

great

the music was great
the animation was great
the story line was great
it was great all together

23450 responds:

That review was....great man. well done. lol.

[Provincial Practice]

good

you rock that was awesome the animation was good the music was great the lotr soundtrack really fit the setting i loved it

23450 responds:

hmm. suprised you caught the referance. I barely do. lol. The one shining element in this has always been the story. Always touched people more then all my others. With good reason.

[Owl Salvation]

great!

only a few thing the animation on the owl was......ummm just ok...
the story was good and the music was cool too lol
there was one part where the grass is kinda messed up but other than that it was great

23450 responds:

Another quick job. I tryed to makie it look good, sure, but theres only so much i can do, and when im at school practicing, i dont do as a good a job when im in competition. Thanks for enjoying it though.

[Hostile encounter]

Good but....

it was good but it was really kinda pointless and kinda short but the animation was good
and the song and sound effect were good but,
kinda just pointless
i did like the idea of it tho

23450 responds:

Nothing wrong with a little mindless violence every once and a while. I mean, i loved 300. Not much more in there then violence. Could have done more with mine though. Lazy me.

[DOG]

cool

the animation was good
the story was funny
the sound effect were good
it was just GOOD all together!

23450 responds:

Unfourtunatly, it wasn't so much funny as it was amusing. But i was happy with it either way. I did put alot of work into the sound effect, so hopefully everyone else noticed. Thanks for the review.

[Deep Sea Mutilation]

good

i like it just maybe you could make it a little longer but the animation was good and the sound effect were good

23450 responds:

Do not see a point in making it longer. The point was simply a mysteriouse animal and faceless crewman getting slaughtered by it. Making it longer would have caused me to flesh out more elements, lossing some of the mystery. Because if i make it longer without explaining things, then it gets borring.

And im happy you liked the ound effects. Really was the main reason i made it.